12 Comments Already

superelectric Said,
March 1st, 2010 @11:52 am  

what do you feel when you hear about tribes living all alone in the jungles away from civilization?
such as: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1022822/Incredible-pictures-Earths-uncontacted-tribes-firing-bows-arrows.html

These people have never met outsiders. I just find it so fascinating that there are people in this day and age of technology and rapid communication, who still live as if it was 1000 years earlier.. it’s almost like going back into the past.

rhsaunders Said,
March 1st, 2010 @11:54 am  

I don’t envy them their dental problems.
References :

CogitoErgoCogitoSum Said,
March 1st, 2010 @11:56 am  

Evolutionary dead-ends. I feel sorry for tribes that havent even discovered adobe yet. Many generations of suffering and death when there could have been simple remedies. Not to sound insulting, but do you want to feed them knowledge and culture? If they can handle it, so be it. But perhaps they are that way for a reason – a genetic limitation – that you dont want to welcome into the world gene-pool via "domestication"

I respect their cultures though. Dont get me wrong, I have personally adopted the Star Treks "Prime Directive". I dont agree with meddling in or altering anothers culture, particularly if they are weak minded and easily swayed by the prospects of positive change. Its sad when a culture dies, becomes extinct. I myself am part Native American, but I know nothing of that part of my heritage. I respect diversity, I respect history… and we should learn from the mistakes of history… and I respect the sanctity and purity of an untouched culture. Unfortunately, there is no way to fully learn the culture without submersing ones self… and that requires interaction… and with interaction, a loss of purity occurs. Really, its best never to discover the tribe exists than to know about it and let our thirst for knowledge corrupt it.

In some ways those cultures are exotic. In some ways romanticized. There is honor in the savage, or so they say. But I wouldnt want my offspring and descendents to be a part of it, knowing nothing else. I expect a better life for them, and so I do see superiority in technological civilization… and the culture it breeds. We may envy their "simplicity"… they dont have to worry about money or vehicular accidents… but its not simple! They still have to worry about the powerful civilized people that could wipe them out, the neighboring tribe could wage war, the weather may destroy, the droughts may starve, the lions and tigers may ravage and kill. Could you sleep so well if every day was a test of survival? We civilized types may have nuclear bombs, but our civility also prevents us from using it. The neighboring tribe, on the other hand, could wage war because "the gods deemed it" (really the senile elder saw it in a delusion)… but hey, thats simple, right? You and I go to a restaurant or a grocery store to eat. Imagine being too hungry to hunt for the very food you need.

But then again, our culture is far from virtuous. We do not live in harmony with nature. Our arrogance destroys our world. Pollution, endangered species. Of course, crime, violence run rampant. Pornography is ignored, abortion is ignored. Far from virtuous.

Our greatest worry in life isnt survival… its whether or not our cause is heard. Whether or not our boss, our politicians, our society will yield to and conform to our opinions. Whether or not what we think is subjectively right will be adopted by all.

Id be willing to change their world if they formally asked. Its one thing to show yourself and be rejected by them. But what are the chances youd be rejected in every aspect? They would eagerly welcome chance, depending on how and what and why and what was expected in return. It would be rude and selfish to involve yourself for your sake, for your thirst of anthropological knowledge, without giving a little back. They will lose faith, respect, and courtesy with their scientific visitors after a while.

Its quite another thing to take it upon yourself not to show yourself, or to withhold knowledge… rationalized, self-righteously thinking you are doing them a favor by preserving their way of life. Our concerns for their cultural purity and preservation is trumped by our lack of concern for the individuals involved. Does it make sense to cut down the trees in order to save the forest?

It works both ways. Its irresponsible and immoral for us to withhold knowledge. And equally so for us to force it upon them. Whatever we do, the cultural bias must not be imposed, either.
References :

peterpumpkineater73 Said,
March 1st, 2010 @11:58 am  

I wonder why I haven’t joined them to get away from it all, then I read National Geographic and quickly remember.
References :

Gerard M Said,
March 1st, 2010 @12:00 pm  

Pesumably they live in tune with the laws of nature and take no more than they need. Exemplary!
References :

F Said,
March 1st, 2010 @12:02 pm  

I dont really feel anything for these people. They are living the way they always have.
References :

MidwesternTyrant Said,
March 1st, 2010 @12:04 pm  

How they are not missing a thing.
References :

nice2jive Said,
March 1st, 2010 @12:06 pm  

that is so amazing ! it is not only written in history book or hear those once upon a time story ,it is real ,it does exist ,let just be proud ,tribes like them are endangered.
References :

Mr.Miller Said,
March 1st, 2010 @12:08 pm  

I envy the simplicity of their lives. I once had an a chance to visit Batak Tribe here in Palawan. I was amazed of how they live a very simple lives until we encroached their ancestral lands. It is sad because they were forced to accept to live in a civilized society because they have no choice. They have nowhere else to go. Seeing and experiencing that, my realization is life can be simple but we choose to live in a very complicated world.
References :

aegispathos Said,
March 1st, 2010 @12:10 pm  

With the pressures of modern day society the naturalness of their existence can seem appealing on the surface but I imagine it comes with it’s own hardships.

I wonder how aware they are of the ‘outside world’. There must be some knowledge there judging from the aggressive stance directed at the aircraft flying over. They many never have met other people face to face but they have definitely encountered outsiders and decided they want none of it.

In the UK we have communities that have decide to ‘go back to nature’ by choice and it must be difficult initially to truly put behind all the technological and medical advances made.

Ideally, by choice, I would like the best of both ways of life. The creature comforts we have developed to make life easier but without all the normal constraints imposed by living in a highly developed and sophisticated society and the right to live a life that gives more room for personal freedom.
References :

foodoogeek Said,
March 1st, 2010 @12:12 pm  

Fascinated… excited. Thrilled there are people and things we haven’t discovered yet. In touch with the mystery of it all.

Awe.
References :

mtheoryrules Said,
March 1st, 2010 @12:14 pm  

Passing curiosity.
References :
You asked.

Related Post

Leave Your Comments Below

Please Note: All comments will be hand modified by our authors so any over offensive comments will be removed and your submitted comments will be appreared after approved

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree Plugin

Security Code:

N/A

  • Lucky Me in The Old and the New Swiss Army Knif…
  • devin b in The Old and the New Swiss Army Knif…
  • morgan in The Old and the New Swiss Army Knif…
  • Metroguy in The Old and the New Swiss Army Knif…
  • aussieguyliam in The Old and the New Swiss Army Knif…
  • da1nonly in This should have been a fox!
  • ????™ in This should have been a fox!
  • Stupid Genius in This should have been a fox!
  • mandy in This should have been a fox!
  • Perri in This should have been a fox!
  • Tenacious 1 1 1 1 1

Take Our Poll

Top Commentators

    • No commentators.

Search

Categories

Meta

Archives

Pages

Links

flickr

who blog this